Sunday, April 7, 2013

William Carlos Williams – “As the Cat”


I am delighted to have the good fortune of sharing an analysis on William Carlos Williams's "As the Cat." The short poem paints a picture of a cat that climbs up on top of a "jamcloset" (Williams 4), then proceeds to carefully step down into an empty flowerpot; that's the whole poem. While simple enough on the first read, the real fun of a Williams poem comes in the interpretation of it all. What does it mean? I can only speculate on the true meaning behind this extended metaphor, but here is my attempt at interpreting it.
            Upon searching Webster's dictionary I discovered that jamcloset is not actually a word; this leads me to believe that since the cat climbed over something called a jamcloset, this could be a metaphor for someone maneuvering their way above a "sticky" situation. The "jam" prefix could be interpreted two ways: it could either refer to the verb jam which means to pack something into a space (a closet for example), or it could refer to the jam that one spreads on toast. The verb jam could translate into a tight situation, and the noun jam could translate to a sticky situation. The cat's right forefoot moves "carefully" (7). This lets the reader understand that he has a destination in mind which is revealed at the end. After carefully moving over the top of the jamcloset, the cat then "step[s] down" into  "the pit of / then empty / flowerpot" (9-12). The way that the cat moves suggests that this final destination is premeditated. Cats generally feel safer when they are low to the ground or inside something (like a box or a flowerpot). The juxtaposition of the jamcloset and the empty flowerpot can represent the idea of danger and safety. It is sometimes in human nature to avoid situations representative of the jamcloset and stay wherever we are secure; security can be found in a physical location, a state of mind, or anything of the like where a person feels comfortable.
            Referring to the emptiness of the flowerpot as "the pit" (10) has some negative connotations if applied to the metaphor I am trying to create. A pit is generally referred to as a hole where someone cannot escape. Usually people fall into pits; however, the cat steps down into this pit. This could mean (if we stick with this same metaphor) that we as people consciously choose our own downfalls. Security is a downfall because it is usually not pliable to change. We constantly maneuver our way around dangerous situations to find our hole, and in this sense we fallen into a pit of comfort, which can hinder the way we live. The cat's forefoot that carefully moved first down towards the pot is referred to as the "right" forefoot (5). While some people envision right meaning the opposite of left, I choose to see it as the opposite of wrong. The cat sees that his move down into the pot is the "right" decision, as opposed to staying by the jamcloset, which may be the "wrong" decision to him.
            This poem is fantastic in its simplicity because it invites many interpretations. In a way I believe that a cat is an excellent choice for this poem as opposed to some other animal. The way that a cat moves reflects the way that people move through uncomfortable situations in life. We know what we want: safety; yet we are generally tender-footed when in new situations. It is in human nature to have a destination in mind.     - Kennedy Pope

11 comments:

  1. After reviewing the poem, I think I agree more with the idea that the "pit" is a negative place. the poem is a metaphor for how a person handles a certain situation. The person finds itself in a "sticky" situation, only to fall down into comfort rather than solve the problem; however, I can see how it can be interpreted as a positive poem as well. I find William Carlos Williams' work fascinating because even in their simplicity, so much meaning can be inferred. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree that this poem is completely open to interpretation. I like the fact that people are being compared (or contrasted) to cats. Cats are very deliberate with their movements, which is how we as humans should be. Cats also prefer safety and comfort over adventure and spontaneity. As humans we also tend to fall into this category. We fall into a sort of pattern in our daily lives and refuse to push the boundaries because change is not always a good thing, and it certainly isn't comfortable. Excellent analysis, especially for such a short poem!

    ReplyDelete
  3. This really makes me want to read this poem for the simplicity of it and for the different meanings it could have. Cats are very curious creatures and while meaning people don't like them, I happen it love them. They are free so to speak and do whatever they want but like you said are very careful around things. Humans, too, are careful around different situations and like cats don't change our way of life. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I personally do not like cats. With that said...I find it fascinating how Williams takes on the perspective of a cat. I really like how you tied the characteristics of humans with those of cats at the end. It definitely gives a new viewpoint. Great analysis of the poem!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree that such a simple poem is open to interpretation, and I find your interpretation quite intriguing. The extended metaphor of intentionally moving toward safety is quite plausible. I also like your in-depth look at the word "jamcloset". I really feel that the connotation used and the break-down of the word provides a great metaphor and sufficient evidence to back up your position of the poem's meaning.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I love poems that leave so much open to interpretation! It is fun to speculate about all the different possible meanings. I think it is interesting, like you mentioned in your analysis, that the flower pot can been seen as a good and a bad symbol.
    When I think of a cat what automatically comes to mind is the gracefulness they are typically associated with. They can maneuver their way out of tricky situations with their balance, flexibility and speed. However, they also are only comfortable with certain situations (A bath, for example, is definitely out of their comfort zone.) I liked how you mentioned that we as humans also like to stay in our comfort zone and avoid what we see as sticky situations.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I looked up this poem because I was curious.....and I LOVE CATS. Upon, reading said poem, I now love it too! Cats are fascinating because they are so careful with their movements, as if each step is predetermined. I think that the "empty flower pot" could symbolize spontaneity, the unknown. The cat symbolizes us in the way that we are often afraid to delve where we know not. Our movements are always too careful, too planned.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I find beauty in the simplicity of life. It is amazing how authors are able to take a simple plot (like a cat climbing up on a "jamcloset" and stepping down onto a flowerpot) and use words and metaphors to make such situations seem intriguing to readers. I only wish that I had the ability and talent to do so as well.
    - Emily Alves

    ReplyDelete
  10. I have never read this poem and now I need to. From reading your analysis, I think I would enjoy the simplicity of it. I also agree with Carrie in that we plan too much and that can take the fun out of life. I like to be spontaneous but it can also be scary. Great analysis!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Poem is something that begins with some initiation and ends with process like that of a cat's sensing...

    ReplyDelete